music, philosophy, photography, seasons

Seasons & Theodicy

I bring some seasonality indoors with rotating decorations, mostly artificial versions of whatever is blooming outdoors.  Pondering three displays (for spring, summer, and fall) sends me in an unexpected direction.


20230624_215950Rot_-0.8_crop.1_840x655
20230911_214326_rot+0.7_crop.1_blem_840x707
20231018_103618_crop.1_840x744
20231012_090919_blem_eras_rot-1.4_crop.1_840x1138

While fall is my favorite season and fond memories help my cloud vase with mixed mums be my favorite fall decoration, I don’t let it get stale from being on display all year.  Nor do I yearn to see real mums blooming and real leaves turning every day.  Must I experience mud season to appreciate fall?  No, I just need to experience the other major seasons and their different delights, such as dogwoods in spring or roses in summer.

It’s the same with music.  While Brahms’ Intermezzo in A (Opus 118, #2) is among my favorite short piano pieces, I don’t want to hear it 24/7 on my radio.

Must I sometimes hear fingernails on a chalkboard to renew my appreciation for Brahms’ good music?  No, I just need variety in the good music I hear.  Brahms one day and Brubeck another.  Remember this if U hear somebody either shrug off evil (as yin to complement the yang of goodness) or claim to solve the Problem of Evil by saying we “need” evil to appreciate goodness, just as we (supposedly) “need” darkness to appreciate light.  Ain’t so easy.

– Gray button (upper left corner) reveals widgets, –
– above post (on phone) or beside it (on desktop). –

5 thoughts on “Seasons & Theodicy

  1. Like food, the weather, possibly anything we can sense — I can’t think of any positive that needs the existence of, or comparison to, a negative to appreciate it. Yet the notion persists. Hm.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Tho I tend to take breathing freely for granted, a few days of misery from a cold is enough to shake off my complacency.  People with cystic fibrosis are in constant danger of being suffocated by their own mucus.  While we don’t need diseases like CF in the world to appreciate breathing freely or any other aspect of good health, maybe we do need minor ailments.

      Liked by 1 person

Care to comment?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.